South Park and Disability

You don’t need me to tell you that there has been something of a rise in portrayals of disabled people on TV in the past few years, whether it’s long-running shows like Atypical, The A Word and even the short-lived American sitcom Speechless. But there is one show that some might say handles its disabled characters better than most and this may sound surprising but I’m talking about South Park.

South Park has of course been a staple of adult animated TV and has been airing since 1997, its primary aim being to mock and satirise anything that can be satirized and using its wide range of characters to do so.

South Park and disability actually go a long way back, longer than you might expect. In fact they go all the way back to the show’s second season in the episode Conjoined Fetus Lady where all the boys are frightened of the school nurse because she has a dead foetus attached to her head. The townspeople proceed to go overboard in paying tribute to her which she doesn’t like at all. The satirical point being made here feels clichéd and obvious, being that if they really wanted to treat the nurse as an equal they would have been better just leaving her to do her job instead of making themselves look good by coming across as accepting of her. Again the point is obvious, you really don’t need much foresight to see where the episode is going to go.

South Park’s most notable element is of course the offensive, crude and at the best of times controversial humour. It would feel somewhat right to assume any episode of a show like this tackling disability would just be an endless barrage of mockery and ridicule. But much like the episode I mentioned above there are several instances where this is not the case.

When talking about South Park and its disabled characters there’s no doubt which one springs to mind first – a certain wheelchair-bound boy who aside from a few blink-and-you’ll-miss-them moments, doesn’t say anything other than his own name. This is of course Timmy who has been part of the show since its fourth season and quickly became one of the show’s most iconic characters. Of course there was some reluctance about Timmy, mainly from Comedy Central executives who were afraid of accusations of stereotyping. Their concern is understandable but in the long run there was only so much that could be done with a character like Timmy.

Fast forward a year later to the show’s fifth season where a new disabled character joins the show. This time it’s Jimmy Valmer, an aspiring comic who walks with crutches, has suspected cerebral palsy and also stutters. Much like Timmy he’s gone on to become one of the show’s most iconic characters and while It’s just my personal opinion I think Jimmy is more enjoyable than Timmy. Both of them clearly have their fans and it really wouldn’t surprise me if a majority of them are disabled people.  

While there are several disabled characters on South Park, just about all of them except for the nurse have one thing in common, all of them are children. Timmy and Jimmy are actually part of the same class as the main four characters. Aside from them having disabilities there is no arguing that they are equal among the others. Their disabilities never get an undue amount of focus, both have had episodes more or less devoted to them and most of all they are used as part of the show’s brand of humour, but never in a way that would suggest condescension or offence.

It may be hard for recent viewers to imagine, but when Jimmy first appeared he unintentionally started off a rivalry with Timmy that culminated in what Cartman called a “cripple fight”. That was also the name of the episode in which this all happened. The title may sound offensive to some but in this case I don’t think I could have put it better myself. It may be a little jarring to see this violent feud turn to a friendship just a few seasons later and both characters act as if nothing happened.

Of course South Park does have episodes where disability-related issues and themes are the main point and it’s these where Jimmy and Timmy are often front and centre.

One of the show’s most iconic episodes is Up The Down Steroid from its eighth season where Jimmy and Timmy are both participating in the Special Olympics, and after finding out about the cash prize for the winner, Cartman decides he will fake being disabled so he can get it for himself. The joke winds up being that the supposedly able-bodied Cartman can barely make it through a single event without struggling, while the disabled contestants who actually put in the time and effort to train all finish before him. While all that is going on, Jimmy is taking steroids and the only person who finds out is Timmy and he can’t tell anyone. In the end Jimmy owns up to his cheating and much like the nurse episode I think it illustrates well the way South Park handles its disabled characters.

I can’t talk about South Park and disability without talking about the eleventh season episode Le Petit Tourette. It’s very similar to the Special Olympics episode, with Cartman faking something. This time he pretends to have Tourette’s syndrome after seeing a boy in a toy shop struggle with it.  This leads him to think he can say whatever he wants and there will be no consequences. At the time of making it, this episode did get some attention from the Tourette’s Syndrome Association who were prepared for the worst, but in the end it was a lot better than they thought it was going to be, especially in its research of the condition. Uncontrollable profanity might be Tourette’s most well-known form, but there are other lesser-known ones, as a scene with Kyle and other kids with Tourette’s demonstrates.

There is also the episode Krazy Kripples from the seventh season, where Jimmy is annoyed that Christopher Reeve who became disabled in later life due to an accident, and was not born disabled like him and Timmy, is getting attention for his advocacy of stem cell research. This time around Jimmy and Timmy join a gang called the Crips, thinking it would be full of people born disabled, but they remain oblivious to what seems clear to everyone else. Anything about this episode that’s related to disability comes from the show’s portrayal of Reeve who sucks foetuses dry and with each one he is able to move another part of his body.

If the executives of Comedy Central were worried about what negative reactions Jimmy and Timmy might have caused but ultimately didn’t, I can only imagine what the response was to the closest person Jimmy has to an enemy who is also disabled. This of course is Nathan who has Down Syndrome, always has his head at an angle, has a sidekick called Mimsy whom he routinely hits, and who hates Jimmy with a passion.

This is all established in the fourteenth season episode Crippled Summer where Jimmy, Timmy, Nathan and Mimsy all attend a summer camp for disabled kids. While there, Nathan has one goal which is to kill Jimmy. He tries using various methods like putting a poisonous snake in a boat, rigging a ukulele to explode and using a shark whistle while Jimmy is surfing in water. The consequences of his failures to complete his objective are played for laughs. It could earn some minor disapproval but as Nathan is meant to be viewed as the villain the audience is expected to want to see him fail. He is also the one who gave Jimmy the steroids back in Season 8, but back then he was nothing more than a drug dealer. This which would get something of a call-back years later when he was dealing something else entirely – streaming service passwords. It was this episode for me where Nathan really came into his own. It has been pointed out that the other campers do look like Looney Tunes characters but I don’t think there is much in the way of hard evidence to say if this was done to be offensive.

Nathan’s villainous nature is often put in contrast with Jimmy being his polar opposite. It’s also worth noting that Nathan actively plays up the stereotypes of people with his condition when in front of adults. He also has a really annoying smug look on his face which sometimes works a little too well and makes it feel strangely cathartic when he’s beaten up by someone he thought he could control like Mimsy. When Nathan features in an episode it’s nearly always Jimmy he’s up against, the only exception being the eighteenth season episode Handicar where it was him vs Timmy. Jimmy’s involvement only goes as far as being in a background shot.

Not every South Park where Timmy and Jimmy are prominent either together or separately is necessarily about disability. In the aforementioned Handicar episode it takes something of a backseat. It just happens to be about Timmy having his own business of drivers for hire which Nathan doesn’t like and tries to stop. The only disability-related element is that the money from Handicar will go to funding another summer camp for South Park’s disabled children. Timmy did have a few other episodes to himself, mostly in his first set of appearances like the fourth season’s Timmy 2000 where he leads a successful band and in the same season Heller Keller – The Musical where he plays the titular role and develops a bond with a disabled turkey he calls Gobbles.

Along with occasionally being part of the main boys’ group of friends, Jimmy is the main character in episodes about a variety of subject matters, ranging from free speech and journalistic integrity along with the less than pleasant nature of advertising. As he is meant to be an aspiring comedian it only makes sense to give him focus in episodes about the nature of comedy, like the fifteenth season episode Funnybot. Other episodes have seen him struggle with bodily problems and how far he will go to fix them. He was also the only one who seemed to be taking the running of a news show seriously when other classmates and the main four were more than happy to stoop low in order to achieve ratings.

Jimmy, Timmy, Nathan and Mimsy rarely have an episode together and for the few times they have, the one in the camp was the only one that could have been said to be disability-focused… while also not being disability-focused. Something similar happened in the twenty-first season with the episode Moss Piglets where the four disabled boys may be involved in the main plot but it’s just a matter of one pair wishing to sabotage the other pair’s science experiment but instead actually making it more impressive.

I would like to think that this demonstrates two things. One is that Jimmy and Timmy are without a doubt the right characters to use when covering anything related to disability. They can function as a pair but also work well alone and in episodes not about disability.

This is all very well but I must point out that there are times where a character’s disability is used as the main point of a joke. The two main examples actually come from Jimmy’s early days in the show. The first one being in the sixth season finale Red Sleigh Down – he is invited to turn on the Christmas lights but before doing that, he insists on singing The Twelve Days Of Christmas and of course stutters, so that by the end of the episode he’s still not even halfway – despite the audience being either asleep or very patient, and he had promised to be “real quick.”

The other example is the seventh season episode Raisins where Stan tries to get Jimmy to deliver a message to his girlfriend Wendy. Once again due to his stutter, it comes out sounding like a very bad obscenity. Again they are nothing more than minor jokes, so small that it may not even be worth getting offended or taking any real notice.

In fact, the only disabled character on South Park who has more or less always been used as a joke is the lisping and diabetes-stricken Scott Malkinson; but his appearances are so few it’s easy to forget he’s even part of the already large cast of characters.

I’ve never been one to issue demands to see more disabled people in TV or films. In fact, in most cases I couldn’t care less about it. But in the case of South Park, a show that revels in offence, they somehow have two major characters plus others with disabilities and the response to their representation has often been very good. I know I am not the first person to bring this up as there are various articles online about this, as well as videos on YouTube.

When Timmy first appeared on the show in 2000 I don’t think many people were demanding that the show have disabled characters, yet they still got one, they eventually warmed to him and that led to a few more. Many films and TV shows may think they are portraying disability well but to me, South Park really seems to excel at it. The main reasons being, the characters are equal among the others, they are not portrayed as flawless saints and they occasionally do bad things which other shows might flinch from showing. I also don’t get offended if a disabled person is portrayed in a way that is alleged to be wrong by the majority, those are especially the situations where I just don’t have the energy to care.

The presence of disabled people in films and on TV is probably only going to increase as the years go on, but it’s remarkable that the show with perhaps the best disability representation around is also the same show where a kid ground two people’s remains into some chilli and fed them to their son. Now that really is something to think about.

Leave a comment